top of page

The Sane Perspective - November 2026

Sane Health & Safety
Nov 4
5 min read

Updated: Nov 5

Three people wearing high-visibility vests having a discussion on a construction site.

When Safety Becomes a Tick-Box Exercise: Are We Measuring What Really Matters?


By Jason Beer CertIOSH | Sane Health & Safety Ltd


Throughout my career in health and safety, I've come across plenty of organisations that have invested considerable time and effort into developing their safety arrangements.


Policies, procedures, risk assessments, inspections, audits, training records and action trackers.


All important, and all capable of contributing to a safer working environment.


But something I've found myself reflecting on more often is whether we're always measuring the things that really matter.


Because there's a difference between demonstrating that a process has been completed and understanding whether that process is actually making a difference.


And I think it's a distinction worth exploring.


When compliance becomes the objective


Let's be clear. Compliance matters.


Organisations have legal responsibilities, and having suitable arrangements in place is an essential part of managing health and safety effectively.


But I've seen situations where completing the process appears to have become more important than understanding what the process is supposed to achieve.


An inspection gets completed because it's due.


A risk assessment gets reviewed because the review date has arrived.


A toolbox talk or safety briefing is delivered, and everyone signs the attendance sheet.


An action is marked as closed.


All positive activities, potentially.


But what happens if we look a little deeper?


Did the inspection identify anything meaningful?


Did the risk assessment reflect how the work is actually being carried out?


Did the people attending the briefing understand what was discussed?


And did closing that action genuinely reduce the risk?


Completing the process is important. Understanding whether it worked is even more important.


What are we actually measuring?


It's understandable that organisations want to measure health and safety performance.


We need information to identify trends, monitor progress and understand where improvements are required.


And numbers can help us do that.


But I sometimes wonder whether we place too much emphasis on what is easiest to count.


The number of inspections completed.


The percentage of actions closed.


The number of employees trained.


The number of days without an accident.


These figures can provide useful information, but they don't necessarily tell us the whole story.


For example, a workplace might achieve an excellent inspection completion rate while repeatedly identifying the same issues.


Another might report very few near misses, but is that because risks are being effectively managed or because people don't feel comfortable reporting them?


And a high percentage of closed actions doesn't automatically tell us whether the underlying problems have been addressed.


A good-looking set of figures doesn't always mean we have a good understanding of what's happening in practice.


That's why I believe we need to look beyond the numbers and consider what they're actually telling us.


The value of getting out and speaking to people


One of the things I've always valued about working in health and safety is the opportunity to spend time with the people carrying out the work.


Whether that's on a construction project, in a warehouse, a manufacturing environment or another workplace, there's a great deal we can learn simply by asking questions and listening.


How is the work actually being carried out?


Are the agreed control measures practical?


Is the right equipment available?


Are people experiencing difficulties that haven't been recognised?


And do they feel comfortable raising concerns?


These conversations can provide a much clearer picture of how effectively health and safety arrangements are working.


Sometimes they confirm that things are going well.


Other times, they highlight issues that aren't immediately obvious from the documentation.


And occasionally, they reveal that a process which looks perfectly reasonable on paper is creating unnecessary difficulties for the people expected to follow it.


For me, that's valuable information.


Not because it gives us another observation to record, but because it gives us an opportunity to improve something.


Looking beyond the inspection score


I've always believed that a good inspection should be about more than identifying faults.


Of course, we need to recognise unsafe conditions, poor practices and areas where standards aren't being met.


But we should also be looking at why those issues exist.


If the same problem keeps appearing, is it really enough to keep raising and closing the same action?


Or should we be asking whether something more fundamental needs to change?


Perhaps the equipment isn't suitable.


Maybe the work hasn't been properly planned.


There could be conflicting priorities, inadequate resources or arrangements that simply don't reflect the realities of the workplace.


I also think it's important to recognise what's being done well.


A workplace that actively identifies concerns, encourages reporting and takes meaningful action may be demonstrating a healthier approach to safety than one that appears to have very few issues.


The aim shouldn't be to achieve a perfect inspection score. It should be to understand what's happening and make improvements where they're needed.


The danger of adding another procedure


When something goes wrong, it's understandable that organisations want to demonstrate they've taken action.


And sometimes that means reviewing a procedure, updating a risk assessment or introducing additional checks.


There are occasions when that's entirely appropriate.


But I think we should be careful about automatically assuming that more documentation is the answer.


If a control measure isn't being followed, perhaps we need to understand why before introducing another form.


Is the control practical?


Have people been properly involved in developing it?


Does the working environment support its use?


And are managers and supervisors providing the necessary support?


Sometimes the most effective improvement is relatively straightforward.


Better planning.


More suitable equipment.


Clearer communication.


A change to the working environment.


Or simply taking the time to involve the people doing the job.


Good health and safety isn't about creating the most complicated system. It's about having arrangements that work.


Making health and safety meaningful


I don't believe the answer is to stop measuring performance or reduce the importance of documentation.


Quite the opposite.


We need good information, reliable records and effective systems to help organisations manage their responsibilities.


But those arrangements should support good decision-making, not become the objective in themselves.


For me, it's about finding the right balance.


Using inspections to understand workplace conditions, not simply meet a target.


Using risk assessments to identify and manage risks, not just demonstrate that a document exists.


Using incident and near-miss reports to learn, rather than simply record what happened.


And using conversations with the workforce to understand whether our arrangements are genuinely helping people work safely.


Ultimately, I think we need to keep coming back to one question.


Are we making a meaningful difference, or are we simply demonstrating that we've completed the process?


Because there's an important distinction between the two.


Final thoughts


Health and safety will always involve documentation, inspections, audits and performance measures.


And rightly so.


But I believe the real value comes from what we do with the information they provide.


The conversations we have.


The decisions we make.


The improvements we introduce.


And whether those improvements actually help protect the people doing the work.


The real measure of good health and safety isn't how much paperwork we've completed. It's whether the arrangements we've put in place are actually protecting people.


That's something I think is worth remembering, whatever industry we work in.


💭 Do you think organisations sometimes focus too much on demonstrating compliance rather than understanding whether their health and safety arrangements are effective?


I'd be interested to hear your thoughts and experiences.


About Sane Health & Safety Ltd


At Sane Health & Safety Ltd, we believe effective health and safety should be practical, proportionate and focused on making a genuine difference.


We support organisations with risk management, workplace inspections and audits, safe systems of work, compliance and ongoing health and safety advice.


If your organisation would benefit from an independent perspective, we'd be happy to have a conversation.


📱 07816 897342


Advise | Assure | Add Value


Comments


bottom of page